top of page

Does Virginia Really Give Dogs a “Free Bite”?

Writer: Brian
Brian
Nov 13
4 min read

No. Despite the popular saying, Virginia's one-bite rule does not give every dog a free bite before its owner can be held responsible.


The rule asks a different question: did the owner know, or have reason to know, that the dog was dangerous? A prior bite is strong proof of that. It is not the only proof. Virginia courts have also applied the rule to threatening behavior that never involved a bite, such as snarling and baring teeth.


If you were hurt by a dog that had never bitten anyone, you may still have a claim. Here is how Virginia dog bite law works and what can help prove your case.


What Virginia's one-bite rule actually means

Virginia's one-bite rule makes a dog owner responsible when the owner knew or should have known about the dog's dangerous tendencies. Many states have a statute that holds owners liable for nearly any bite. Virginia does not. Its dog bite cases rely largely on rules developed by the courts.


That makes the owner's knowledge a central issue. The name suggests that a dog must bite someone before the owner can be on notice. In practice, an owner can learn that a dog is dangerous in many other ways.


Snarling and baring teeth can count

A dog does not need a bite history for its owner to be on notice. Virginia courts have applied the one-bite rule to aggressive behavior such as baring teeth, snarling, and throwing itself against a window.


The reasoning is practical. A reasonable owner who sees a dog act this way has reason to know it may hurt someone. Evidence of an owner's knowledge might include:

•         Snarling, growling, or baring teeth at visitors or passersby

•         Lunging at people through a fence, door, or window

•         Earlier attacks on people or other animals

•         Complaints from neighbors, or calls to animal control

•         Warnings the owner gave others about the dog

•         Muzzles, "Beware of Dog" signs, or other precautions that suggest the owner was concerned

•         A prior court finding that the dog is dangerous


No single fact decides every case. What matters is what the owner knew or should have known before you were hurt.


The one-bite rule is not your only option

Even with no sign of prior aggression, you may be able to bring a claim on other grounds.

Negligence. An owner who fails to use reasonable care to control a dog may be liable for the harm that follows. Examples include leaving a gate open or letting a dog run loose near children.

Violating a leash or animal control law. Many Virginia localities have leash and confinement ordinances. In Virginia, breaking a law designed to protect the public can establish negligence, a concept known as negligence per se. Local rules vary, so the location of the attack matters.

Dangerous dog findings. Virginia courts can declare a dog dangerous, which triggers registration, confinement, and insurance requirements. The public can search the state's Dangerous Dog Registry, and a listing can be useful evidence that an owner knew of the risk.


Two Virginia rules that can end a claim

Contributory negligence. Virginia is one of the few states that follow this strict rule. If you are found even slightly at fault for your injuries, you may be barred from recovering anything. Insurers often look for signs that a victim provoked the dog, or ignored a warning.

The two-year deadline. Most Virginia personal injury lawsuits, including dog bite claims, must be filed within two years of the injury. Miss that deadline and the court will likely dismiss your case. Different timing can apply in some situations, so it is best to ask a lawyer early.


What to do after a dog bite in Virginia

Proof of a dog's past behavior can fade quickly, so start gathering it right away.

1.       Get medical care, even for a bite that seems minor.

2.       Report the bite to your local health department or animal control.

3.       Get the owner's name, address, and the dog's rabies vaccination information.

4.       Take photos of your injuries, the location, and any broken fence, gate, or leash.

5.       Collect names and phone numbers of witnesses and neighbors who have seen the dog act aggressively.

6.       Avoid giving a recorded statement to the owner's insurer before you get legal advice.


Frequently asked questions about Virginia's one-bite rule

Is Virginia a strict liability state for dog bites?

Not in the way many states are. Virginia has no statute that makes owners automatically liable for most bites. Claims usually rest on the one-bite rule, negligence, or the violation of a safety law.


Can a dog owner be liable for a first bite in Virginia?

Yes. An owner may be liable if they knew or should have known the dog was dangerous, or if they were negligent in controlling it.


Does growling count as a warning sign under Virginia law?

It can be relevant. Virginia courts have applied the one-bite rule to snarling and baring teeth, and the full context of the behavior matters.


How long do I have to file a dog bite lawsuit in Virginia?

Generally, two years from the date of the injury.


What if I was partly at fault for the dog attack?

Under Virginia's contributory negligence rule, even a small share of fault may bar recovery. A lawyer can review whether that defense applies to your facts.


Talk to a Virginia dog bite lawyer

A dog's history of snarling or lunging may be the evidence that makes your case. [Firm Name] can investigate what the owner knew, deal with the insurance company, and protect your filing deadline. Call 757-454-2110 or contact us online for a consultation about your Virginia dog bite claim.


This post provides general information and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

 
 
 

Comments


© 2023 Brian A. Thomasson, P.L.C

​

Brian A. Thomasson, P.L.C., and StepUpToBAT is located in Chesapeake, VA, and serves clients in and around Chesapeake, Virginia Beach, Portsmouth, Norfolk, Suffolk, Hampton, Chesapeake City, Chesapeake County, Virginia Beach City County, Norfolk City County, Portsmouth City County, and throughout Virginia.  We handle divorce cases, family law, custody, visitation, support, separation, personal injury, accidents and injury law.

bottom of page